Manufacturing-driven Design: Ensure Your Optimized Designs Are Always Ready for Production

In today's fast-paced product development world, designing a product that looks good on paper is just the beginning. The real challenge is ensuring that these designs can be manufactured efficiently, cost-effectively, and with high quality. This is where the concept of manufacturability becomes predominant in design optimization. But what exactly is manufacturability, and why should it matter to Design Engineers and engineers alike? Let’s delve into this crucial aspect of product development and explore how it can make or break a design.

‍

‍

Understanding Manufacturability in Design Optimization

Manufacturability refers to the ease with which a design can be produced using available manufacturing processes, tools, and materials. It is an essential factor in design optimization, which aims to create products that not only meet functional or aesthetic requirements but also are feasible to produce. Ignoring manufacturability can lead to increased costs, delays, and even design failures, turning a brilliant concept into a logistical nightmare.

‍

Key Manufacturing-Related Factors to Consider When Optimizing a Design

When optimizing designs, Design Engineers need to take into account several key factors :

• Material Selection: Choosing the right material is critical as it affects not only the product’s performance but also the ease of manufacturing. Some materials may require special handling or tooling, which can add to production costs and time.

• Ease of Assembly: Designs that are overly complex can lead to assembly challenges, increasing the risk of errors and defects. Simplifying the design for ease of assembly helps streamline production and reduce labor costs.

• Cost Efficiency: By considering manufacturability early in the design phase, you can avoid expensive modifications later on. This proactive approach helps in managing costs more effectively and ensures a smoother transition from design to production.

• Compatibility with Manufacturing Capabilities: Understanding the limitations and capabilities of different manufacturing processes (like injection molding, CNC machining, or 3D printing) allows designers to tailor their designs accordingly, ensuring that they are feasible to produce.

‍

Common Challenges in Achieving Manufacturability

Despite its importance, achieving manufacturability in design optimization often comes with its own set of challenges such as design complexity, production limitation and material constraints.

First, design complexity poses significant challenges in achieving manufacturability due to the intricate geometries, tight tolerances, and numerous components involved. Complex designs often require specialized manufacturing processes, such as 5-axis CNC machining or additive manufacturing, which are expensive and slow. Tight tolerances demand high-precision equipment and rigorous quality control, increasing costs and the risk of defects.

Additionally, managing many components complicates assembly, raising the potential for errors and delays. Plus, complex designs push the limits of traditional manufacturing methods, leading to difficulties in scaling production and higher scrap rates due to defects like warping or deformation. The need for specialized materials and components can further complicate the supply chain, increasing lead times and costs.

Prototyping and testing are more challenging as well, often requiring multiple iterations to address issues, which delays the time to market. Furthermore, as designs become more complex, the likelihood of mistakes increases, making it harder to ensure that all changes align with both the optimization goals and manufacturing capabilities.

Regarding manufacturing capabilities, we should also highlight that each production process has its own set of limitations. For injection molding, engineers may face challenges in producing complex or thin-walled designs due to material flow issues, which can lead to defects such as warping or incomplete fills. In CNC machining, achieving tight tolerances is particularly challenging with complex geometries, resulting in increased tool wear and longer machining times. 3D printing offers design flexibility but struggles with slow production rates, material limitations, and surface finish quality. Casting processes, such as die casting, encounter difficulties with porosity and maintaining dimensional accuracy in large or detailed parts.

Given that each process has its own constraints, engineers must demonstrate versatility. Technological advancements bring new rules and, therefore, a continuous reassessment of established technical knowledge. New processes introduce less familiar manufacturing rules, necessitating additional training for engineers who are already well-versed in traditional methods. For instance, additive manufacturing appears to be an interesting option for engineers due to the flexibility in the production process. However, since this process remains new for the industry, many engineers may not be fully familiar with the manufacturing rules and constraints of this process, which can lead to errors and increased lead times.

Finally, selecting the right material that balances performance, cost, and manufacturability is often a challenge. Some materials, while ideal for a design's function, may not be easy to work with or may be cost-prohibitive in production.

‍

Strategies for Enhancing Manufacturability in Design Optimization

To overcome these challenges, several strategies can be employed to enhance manufacturability in the design optimization process:

• Design for Manufacturability (DFM): This approach focuses on integrating manufacturability considerations from the early design phase to ensure that the optimized design is practical and feasible. By identifying potential manufacturing issues early, DFM reduces the need for expensive revisions later. Advanced software, like Cognitive Design, enhances this process by incorporating manufacturing-driven design tools that not only meet but exceed traditional manufacturability expectations. These tools enable more precise adjustments and proactive problem-solving, streamlining the transition from design to production and ensuring that complex designs are efficiently and effectively manufacturable.

‍

‍

• Iterative Testing and Prototyping: Creating prototypes and conducting iterative tests are crucial steps in identifying manufacturability issues before mass production. This allows designers to refine their designs based on real-world feedback and avoid costly mistakes.

• Collaborative Design Process: Encouraging collaboration between designers, engineers, and manufacturers can lead to better design decisions. This cross-functional approach ensures that all aspects of manufacturability are considered, resulting in a design that is both innovative and practical.

‍

Introducing Cognitive Design: A Solution for Optimal Manufacturability

Ensuring manufacturability during design optimization can be a significant challenge for Design Engineers. To address this concern, we developed a new software solution called Cognitive Design. Cognitive Design quickly detects potential manufacturing issues, such as wall deformation and feature distortion, and corrects them through automated modifications brought to the design's geometry.

‍

‍

By focusing on a manufacturing-driven design approach, the software ensures maximum feasibility for designs, regardless of their complexity. Thanks to the AM Morpher app, it enables precise adjustments to geometry, offset, ribbing thickness, thermal concentrations, holes, and powder removal parameters.  

Its proprietary geometric engine facilitates easy geometry refinement, ensuring manufacturability and bridging the gap between design and production, thereby streamlining the process from concept to final product by reducing the need for multiple design iterations.

Want to know more about Cognitive Design capabilities? Sign-up for a 60-day FREE trial and get access to all features. Try it out now.